Author: Christophe Chiquet (France)
Co-authors: Thibaud Mautuit, Stephen Hogg, Rachel Semecas, Nicolas Chateau, Emanuele Trucco, Vincent Daien
Purpose
To compare retinal vascular diameter measurements taken from standard fundus images and adaptive optics (AO) images.
Setting/Venue
Prospective comparative study.
Methods
We analyzed retinal images of 20 healthy participants with 45-degree funduscopic color photographs (CR-2 Canon fundus camera, Canon™) and adaptive optics (AO) fundus images (rtx1 camera, Imagine Eyes®). Diameters were measured using three software applications: the VAMPIRE® (Vessel Assessment and Measurement Platform for Images of the REtina) Annotation Tool, IVAN (Interactive Vessel ANalyzer) for funduscopic color photographs, and AO_Detect_Artery™ for AO images.
Results
For the arterial diameters, the mean difference between AO_Detect_Artery™ and IVAN measurements was 9.1 µm (-27.4–9.2 µm, p=0.005) with a significant correlation between measurements (r=0.79). The mean difference between the AO_Detect_Artery™ and VAMPIRE™ Annotation Tool measurements was 3.8 µm (-34.4–26.8 µm, p=0.16) with a weak correlation between measurements (r=0.12). For the venous diameters, the mean difference between the AO_Detect_Artery™ and IVAN measurements was 3.9 µm (-40.9–41.9 µm, p=0.35) with a strong correlation between measurements (r=0.83). The mean difference between the AO_Detect_Artery™ and VAMPIRE™ Annotation Tool measurements was 0.4 µm (-17.44–25.3 µm, p=0.91), and the correlation was moderate (r=0.41).
Conlusions
Taking AO imaging as a reference, we found that the VAMPIRE Annotation Tool, an entirely manual software, provides accurate measurements of the arterial and venular diameters, but the correlation is weak. By contrast, IVAN, a semi-automatic software tool, has slightly higher differences in measurements compared with AO imaging, but the correlation is stronger.
Financial Disclosure
Imagine eyes for Nicolas CHATEAU
Comments
-