Author: haroon tayyab (Pakistan)
Co-authors: saima jamil, Shiraz Hashmi
Purpose
With understandable limitations on the minimalistic size and designs of vitreous cutter, more recent interest has been in the development of dual blade / twin blade cutters that effectively double the cut rate; and at the same time, provide more stable and efficient vitreous fluidics. Furthermore, Dutch Ophthalmic Research Center (DORC) has recently introduced Two Dimensional Cutting (TDC) vitrectome with twin angled blades that promise cut rates up to 16,000 cuts per minute and vastly improved fluidics. Other similar novel twin blade cutter designs include Constant Flow Blade (CFB; Twedge Cutter Blade; Optikon 2000 Inc, Rome, Italy) offering up to 20,000 cuts per minute, Mach2 in megaTRON S4HSP (Geuder, Heidelberg, Germany) and Continuous Flow Cutter in OS4 (Oertli Instruments AG, Switzerland) offering 10,000 cuts per minute. Faster cut rates and small gauge vitrectors have also paved the way for higher infusion pressures. These infusion pressures range from 30mmHg for 20-gauge vitrectomy up to 50 mmHg for 25 and 27-gauge vitrectomy systems. This arrangement facilitates better flow rates through small-bore instruments. The primary objective of this experimental study is to evaluate the efficiency of various vitrectomy platforms as a function of cutter speeds and vacuum in varying in vitro environments.
Setting/Venue
In this in vitro experimental study, we used EVA (Dutch Ophthalmic Research Center, Zuidland, The Netherlands), REVOLUTION (Optikon 2000 Inc, Rome, Italy) and OS4 (Oertli Instruments AG, Switzerland) as vitrectomy platforms. EVA vitrectomy system employs a peristatic pump whereas REVOLUTION and OS4 house both peristatic and venturi pumps. We employed 23-gauge vitrectomy cutters for simplicity and comparison on standardized approach, although smaller gauge cutters were available. For all experiments, we used the dual blade proprietary cutters respective for the machines. this study was conducted in The Aga Khan University, Karachi in 2020.
Methods
We use goat eye vitreous, albumin (egg white) and distilled water as vitreous substitutes. All vitrectomy samples were collected using 23-gauge dual blade cutters of respective vitrectomy platforms. The samples included goat eye vitreous, egg white albumin and distilled water contained in 40ml beaker. The samples were obtained at room temperature of 25 C. The samples contained in beaker were placed on a standard precise (up to 0.01g) micro balance (Ohaus Corporation, Pine Brook, NJ, USA). Vitrectomy was initiated at 1000 cuts / minute at 100 mmHg vacuum pressure. The cut rate was incrementally increased by1000 cuts / minute till the maximum capacity. Similarly, all cut rate increments were measured against varying aspiration rates (increments of 100 mmHg) till the maximum aspiration rate. Vitrectomy cutter was switched on for 30 seconds and 3 separate readings (weight in grams) were taken for every single setting. Measurement of aspirated mass in grams was recorded before the start of vitrectomy and then remeasured after 30 seconds of vitrectomy.
Results
A direct association of aspirated mass and CPM ranging from 1000-10000 was observed at vacuum pressure varying from 100 to 700 mm Hg for all three machines for water. EVA and REVOLUTION aspirated almost similar mass whereas OS4 aspirated low water mass.. For egg white, aspirated mass was higher at 4000 CPM both for EVA and OS4 at 680 and 500 mm Hg of maximum pressure. For REVOLUTION, maximum aspiration was achieved at 7000 CPM and 4000 CPM at 600 and 700 mm Hg pressure respectively, For goat vitreous aspiration, EVA aspirated maximum at 4000, 6000 and 8000 CPM at 680 mm Hg. REVOLUTION aspiration was maximum at 9000 CPM at maximum pressure of 700 mm Hg. OS4 performance was high at maximum CPM and vacuum pressure of 5000 and 500 respectively,
Conlusions
When comparing distilled water flow rate across three cutter platforms, we observed linearly increasing mass aspirated as the vacuum increased. Vitrectomy machine with highest vacuum generation ability (REvolution) has most aspirated at highest vacuum. There was no significant difference in mass aspirated as the cut rate increased; also, the mass aspirated at a certain midrange identical settings also did not differ significantly across three platforms for this Newtonian fluid. This finding is similar to the experiment conducted by Oravecz et al when comparing EVA and megaTRON S4 dual bladed cutters while using water as vitreous substitute. A similar experiment was conducted by Abulon et al where he compared Ultravit 23 and 25+ gauge cutters of Constellation Vision system (Alcon Laboratories, Inc., Forth Worth, TX,USA) in a model eye with water as vitreous substitute. He showed that with port biased open, the flow rate decreased with increasing cut rate for any given vacuum settings. This observation is different from ours as we used dual blade cutters in all our experiments whereas single blade cutter was used in Abilon’s experiment; thus showing superiority of dual blade cutters at maintain stable flow rate across various machine settings.
Financial Disclosure
none
Comments
-