Euretina Logo, Links to homepage.
Euretina Logo, Links to homepage.
  • Events
    • Euretina 2027 Copenhagen
      • Session Submission Terms
    • EuretinaAI: AI in Retina
    • Special Focus Meeting 2027 – Inherited Retinal Diseases
      • Registration
      • Poster Submission
      • Programme
    • Euretina 2026 Vienna
      • On-Demand
      • Congress Daily
      • Welcome
      • Registration
      • Hotels
      • Programme
        • Keynote Lectures
        • Wet Labs
        • WSPOS X EURETINA Paediatric Retina Day
        • World Retina @ Euretina
      • EuroVeRsion Case Contest
      • Exhibitors & Sponsors
      • Abstract Submission
      • Session Submission
      • Euretina Innovation Spotlight (EIS) 2026
      • General Information
        • FAQs
        • Euretina Run
        • Delegate Party
        • Sustainability Plan
        • Meeting Policy
        • Travel Details
        • Press Details
        • Social Media Toolkit
    • Special Focus Meeting 2026 – AI in Retina
      • Registration
      • Post-Event Hub
      • Hotels
      • Programme
      • Keynote
      • Poster Submission
    • Euretina 2025 Paris
      • 2025 Paris On Demand
      • Welcome
      • Congress Daily & Photo Gallery
      • Registration
      • Hotels
      • Programme
        • Keynote Lectures
      • Abstracts
      • Satellite Symposia
      • Abstract Submission
      • Late Breaking Submissions
      • EuroVeRsion Case Contest
      • Exhibitors & Sponsors
      • Euretina Innovation Spotlight (EIS)
      • General Information
        • Sustainability Plan
        • Travel Details
        • Delegate Party
        • Women in Retina Networking Breakfast
        • Press Details
        • Social Media Toolkit
    • Special Focus Meeting 2025 – Ocular Endotamponades
      • About
      • Programme
      • Poster & Video Presentations
    • Future Meetings
    • Upcoming Digital Events
  • Free Resources
    • Webinars
    • Podcasts
    • Case Club Cases
    • Euretina Guidelines
    • Euretina Brief
    • IME ePlatform
  • Membership
  • About
    • Euretina Board
    • Committees
    • Subspecialty Sections
    • Code of Conduct
    • Bye-laws
    • Our Sustainability Commitment
    • 25th Anniversary
      • Euretina Congresses 2001-2025
      • A History of Euretina
  • Opportunities
    • Observership Grant Programme – OPEN
    • RMCR Award Programme – OPEN
    • Mentorship Programme
      • Mentorship Alumni
    • Ramin Tadayoni Award
    • Jacqueline Cigrang AMD Research Grant
    • EBO-Euretina Exam
    • YOURS
      • Ophthalmologica Lecturer Proposal
    • Women in Retina
      • Overview
      • Women in Retina Committee
      • Women in Retina Survey 2026
      • Women in Retina Networking Breakfast 2026
      • Women in Retina Networking Breakfast 2025
      • Interview with Anat Loewenstein
      • Women in Retina Interviews 2025
      • Women in Retina Interviews 2023
      • Euretina White Paper on Gender Diversity
      • Euretina Survey on Gender Diversity
    • BEAVRS VR Database
    • CME Credits
  • Member Login
  • Events
    • Euretina 2027 Copenhagen
      • Session Submission Terms
    • EuretinaAI: AI in Retina
    • Special Focus Meeting 2027 – Inherited Retinal Diseases
      • Registration
      • Poster Submission
      • Programme
    • Euretina 2026 Vienna
      • On-Demand
      • Congress Daily
      • Welcome
      • Registration
      • Hotels
      • Programme
        • Keynote Lectures
        • Wet Labs
        • WSPOS X EURETINA Paediatric Retina Day
        • World Retina @ Euretina
      • EuroVeRsion Case Contest
      • Exhibitors & Sponsors
      • Abstract Submission
      • Session Submission
      • Euretina Innovation Spotlight (EIS) 2026
      • General Information
        • FAQs
        • Euretina Run
        • Delegate Party
        • Sustainability Plan
        • Meeting Policy
        • Travel Details
        • Press Details
        • Social Media Toolkit
    • Special Focus Meeting 2026 – AI in Retina
      • Registration
      • Post-Event Hub
      • Hotels
      • Programme
      • Keynote
      • Poster Submission
    • Euretina 2025 Paris
      • 2025 Paris On Demand
      • Welcome
      • Congress Daily & Photo Gallery
      • Registration
      • Hotels
      • Programme
        • Keynote Lectures
      • Abstracts
      • Satellite Symposia
      • Abstract Submission
      • Late Breaking Submissions
      • EuroVeRsion Case Contest
      • Exhibitors & Sponsors
      • Euretina Innovation Spotlight (EIS)
      • General Information
        • Sustainability Plan
        • Travel Details
        • Delegate Party
        • Women in Retina Networking Breakfast
        • Press Details
        • Social Media Toolkit
    • Special Focus Meeting 2025 – Ocular Endotamponades
      • About
      • Programme
      • Poster & Video Presentations
    • Future Meetings
    • Upcoming Digital Events
  • Free Resources
    • Webinars
    • Podcasts
    • Case Club Cases
    • Euretina Guidelines
    • Euretina Brief
    • IME ePlatform
  • Membership
  • About
    • Euretina Board
    • Committees
    • Subspecialty Sections
    • Code of Conduct
    • Bye-laws
    • Our Sustainability Commitment
    • 25th Anniversary
      • Euretina Congresses 2001-2025
      • A History of Euretina
  • Opportunities
    • Observership Grant Programme – OPEN
    • RMCR Award Programme – OPEN
    • Mentorship Programme
      • Mentorship Alumni
    • Ramin Tadayoni Award
    • Jacqueline Cigrang AMD Research Grant
    • EBO-Euretina Exam
    • YOURS
      • Ophthalmologica Lecturer Proposal
    • Women in Retina
      • Overview
      • Women in Retina Committee
      • Women in Retina Survey 2026
      • Women in Retina Networking Breakfast 2026
      • Women in Retina Networking Breakfast 2025
      • Interview with Anat Loewenstein
      • Women in Retina Interviews 2025
      • Women in Retina Interviews 2023
      • Euretina White Paper on Gender Diversity
      • Euretina Survey on Gender Diversity
    • BEAVRS VR Database
    • CME Credits
  • Member Login
  • September 10, 2021
  • 2021 Abstracts

Pars Plana Vitrectomy Versus Scleral Buckling in Rhegmatogenous Retinal Detachment Repair: A Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials and Observational Studies

Author: Arjan Dhoot (Canada)

Co-authors: Marko Popovic, Prem Nichani, Arshia Eshtiaghi, Aman Sayal, Peter Kertes, Rajeev Muni

Purpose

Pars plana vitrectomy (PPV) and scleral buckling (SB) are two of the most common surgical treatments for rhegmatogenous retinal detachments (RRD). This meta-analysis aimed to compare the efficacy and safety for PPV and SB in RRD repair.

Setting/Venue

Systematic review and meta-analysis.

Methods

A systematic literature review was performed using Ovid MEDLINE, EMBASE, and Cochrane CENTRAL from January 2000 to June 2020. Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) and observational studies reporting on the efficacy and/or safety of PPV and SB for the primary surgical management of RRDs were included. Categorical outcomes were reported as risk ratios (RR) and continuous outcomes were reported as weighted mean differences (WMD) with 95% confidence intervals (CI). A random effects model was used for all analyses. Number needed to treat (NNT) and number needed to harm (NNH) were reported. Risk of bias assessment was conducted with the Cochrane criteria for RCTs and the ROBINS-I tool for observational studies. The primary outcome was final best corrected visual acuity (BCVA). Secondary outcomes were primary and final reattachment rates and the incidence of adverse events.

Results

Across 38 studies, 5225 SB and 9473 PPV eyes were included. Median final follow up was 6 months (range: 1–60). Final BCVA significantly favored SB over PPV (WMD, 0.06 logMAR; 95%CI, 0.01 to 0.11]; P=0.03). Compared to SB, PPV was associated with a higher incidence of cataracts (10.4% vs. 39.8%, respectively; RR, 3.48; 95%CI, 2.48 to 5.16; P<0.00001; NNH, 4) and iatrogenic breaks (0.5% vs. 7.9%, respectively; RR, 6.58; 95%CI, 2.98 to 14.52; P<0.00001; NNH, 12.5). However, PPV was associated with a lower incidence of subretinal/choroidal hemorrhage (0.6% vs. 5.5%, respectively; RR, 0.24; 95%CI, 0.09 to 0.67; P=0.0007; NNH, 20), choroidal detachment (0% vs. 4.1%, respectively; RR, 0.14; 95%CI, 0.04 to 0.54; P=0.004; NNH 12.5), and residual subretinal fluid (3.6% vs. 28.4%, respectively; RR, 0.18; 95%CI, 0.10 to 0.35; P<0.00001; NNH 3.85) compared to SB. PPV and SB had similar primary (86.2% vs. 85.0%, respectively; P=0.62) and final (96.7% vs. 97.8%, respectively; P=0.10) reattachment rates. There were no significant differences in operation time (P=0.52) and adverse event rates including diplopia (P=0.24), anterior chamber inflammation (P=0.27), elevated intraocular pressure (P=0.13), ocular hypertension (P=0.19), iris capture (P=0.84), proliferative vitreoretinopathy development (P=0.81), macular edema (P=0.86), macular hole (P=0.59), and epiretinal membrane formation (P=0.48).

Conlusions

For RRD repair, SB was associated with a better final BCVA compared to PPV. Primary and final reattachment rates were similar between the two procedures. PPV was favored for reduced choroidal detachment, choroidal/subretinal hemorrhage, and residual subretinal fluid while SB was favored for fewer iatrogenic breaks and reduced cataract formation

Financial Disclosure

AD: None, MP: Financial support (to institution) - PSI Foundation, AE: None, AS: None, PN: None, PK: Consultant – Novartis, Alcon, Bayer, Novelty Nobility; Financial support (to institution) – Allergan, Bayer, Roche, Novartis; Financial support – Novartis, Bayer; Equity owner – ArcticDx RM: Consultant – Bayer, Novartis, Allergan, Roche; Financial Support (to institution)- Bayer, Novartis.

Comments

-
PrevPrevious
NextNext
Euretina Logo, Links to homepage.

European Society of Retina Specialists c/o Congrex Switzerland
Reinacherstrasse 131
4053 Basel
Switzerland

T +41 61 686 77 91
F +41 61 686 77 88

General Enquires: [email protected]

Euretina 2026 Vienna

Ophthalmologica

Forum

Opportunities

Memberships

About

Code of Conduct

Privacy Policy

Contact Us

Euretina 2026 Vienna

Ophthalmologica

Forum

Opportunities

Memberships

About

Code of Conduct

Privacy Policy

Contact Us

Newsletter Sign up

By clicking 'Subscribe', you agree to the terms of our Privacy Policy. 
 
 

Follow us

© EURETINA 2026 All rights reserved

  • Events
    • Euretina 2027 Copenhagen
      • Session Submission Terms
    • EuretinaAI: AI in Retina
    • Special Focus Meeting 2027 – Inherited Retinal Diseases
      • Registration
      • Poster Submission
      • Programme
    • Euretina 2026 Vienna
      • On-Demand
      • Congress Daily
      • Welcome
      • Registration
      • Hotels
      • Programme
        • Keynote Lectures
        • Wet Labs
        • WSPOS X EURETINA Paediatric Retina Day
        • World Retina @ Euretina
      • EuroVeRsion Case Contest
      • Exhibitors & Sponsors
      • Abstract Submission
      • Session Submission
      • Euretina Innovation Spotlight (EIS) 2026
      • General Information
        • FAQs
        • Euretina Run
        • Delegate Party
        • Sustainability Plan
        • Meeting Policy
        • Travel Details
        • Press Details
        • Social Media Toolkit
    • Special Focus Meeting 2026 – AI in Retina
      • Registration
      • Post-Event Hub
      • Hotels
      • Programme
      • Keynote
      • Poster Submission
    • Euretina 2025 Paris
      • 2025 Paris On Demand
      • Welcome
      • Congress Daily & Photo Gallery
      • Registration
      • Hotels
      • Programme
        • Keynote Lectures
      • Abstracts
      • Satellite Symposia
      • Abstract Submission
      • Late Breaking Submissions
      • EuroVeRsion Case Contest
      • Exhibitors & Sponsors
      • Euretina Innovation Spotlight (EIS)
      • General Information
        • Sustainability Plan
        • Travel Details
        • Delegate Party
        • Women in Retina Networking Breakfast
        • Press Details
        • Social Media Toolkit
    • Special Focus Meeting 2025 – Ocular Endotamponades
      • About
      • Programme
      • Poster & Video Presentations
    • Future Meetings
    • Upcoming Digital Events
  • Free Resources
    • Webinars
    • Podcasts
    • Case Club Cases
    • Euretina Guidelines
    • Euretina Brief
    • IME ePlatform
  • Membership
  • About
    • Euretina Board
    • Committees
    • Subspecialty Sections
    • Code of Conduct
    • Bye-laws
    • Our Sustainability Commitment
    • 25th Anniversary
      • Euretina Congresses 2001-2025
      • A History of Euretina
  • Opportunities
    • Observership Grant Programme – OPEN
    • RMCR Award Programme – OPEN
    • Mentorship Programme
      • Mentorship Alumni
    • Ramin Tadayoni Award
    • Jacqueline Cigrang AMD Research Grant
    • EBO-Euretina Exam
    • YOURS
      • Ophthalmologica Lecturer Proposal
    • Women in Retina
      • Overview
      • Women in Retina Committee
      • Women in Retina Survey 2026
      • Women in Retina Networking Breakfast 2026
      • Women in Retina Networking Breakfast 2025
      • Interview with Anat Loewenstein
      • Women in Retina Interviews 2025
      • Women in Retina Interviews 2023
      • Euretina White Paper on Gender Diversity
      • Euretina Survey on Gender Diversity
    • BEAVRS VR Database
    • CME Credits
  • Member Login